Fascinating facts about people, places and things
A person laces running shoes by a frosted window on a dark winter morning, with a notebook of goals open on a nearby table.
Rare & Remarkable Human Traits

Why Do New Year's Resolutions Fail?

Most resolutions don't fail in week one. See what the studies actually measured, why goals break down, and how to set a plan that survives a slip.

It's mid-January. You missed the gym twice this week, the budget app has gone quiet, and a voice in your head says the year's plan is already ruined. That moment is where most resolutions fail. The goal itself is rarely the problem. Resolutions tend to break down when the goal is bigger than the time and energy you actually have, when a reward right now beats a benefit months away, when the plan has no answer for an ordinary bad day, or when one slip gets treated as the end. Each of those has a fix, and there are three weeks left to set them up.

Do most resolutions really fail?

Many fewer than the headlines claim, at least in the studies that tracked real people. The answer also depends on what "fail" means and when someone checks. Three studies are worth knowing:

  • Pew Research Center, January 2024. Pew surveyed 5,140 US adults on January 16–21, 2024, weighted to represent the adult population. Thirty percent said they had made at least one resolution for 2024. Of those, 59% said they had kept all of them so far, 28% had kept some and 13% had kept none. Limitation: this is self-reported and only about two to three weeks into the year.
  • Norcross and Vangarelli, 1988. John C. Norcross and Dominic J. Vangarelli followed 200 New Year's resolvers for two years. Seventy-seven percent kept their pledges for one week, and 19% kept them for two years. Limitation: a small sample from decades ago, and the success rate falls steadily as the follow-up gets longer.
  • Norcross, Mrykalo and Blagys, 2002. This team followed 159 resolvers and 123 people who wanted to make a similar change but hadn't made a resolution, interviewing them by phone over six months. At six months, 46% of resolvers reported continuous success, compared with 4% of the nonresolvers. Limitation: people chose which group they were in. The study doesn't prove that making a resolution caused the difference.

Taken together, a large share of people are still on track in mid-January, roughly half of resolvers in one study were still succeeding at six months, and about one in five kept going for two years. That's a gradual decline, not a collapse in week one.

Who makes resolutions also varies. In Pew's survey, 49% of adults ages 18–29 made at least one, compared with 31% of those 30–49 and 21% of those 50 and older. Among resolution-makers, 79% had health goals, 61% money goals, 57% relationship goals, 55% hobby or interest goals and 49% career goals.

The popular failure numbers, checked

Every December the same figures come back. Here's how they hold up:

  • "Only 8% or 9% succeed." Yale, health-system explainers and newspapers repeat this, but none of them points to a single representative study with a clear definition of success and a stated follow-up period. Treat it as unverified.
  • "80% fail by February" or "90% by the second week of February." These precise deadlines circulate widely without a primary dataset you can check.
  • "88% fail within two weeks." Baylor College of Medicine quotes this without naming a study. A medical school publishing a number doesn't make it established.
  • "77% fail in the first week." This one gets the research backward. Norcross and Vangarelli found that 77% kept their pledges for one week.

The bigger problem is that these numbers mix different measures. Keeping every resolution is different from keeping some of them, and keeping a pledge is different from reaching a result. A January check, a six-month check and a two-year check are three different questions. One headline figure can't answer all of them.

Successful people slipped too

The most useful finding from the 1988 study isn't the 19%. It's that 53% of the people who succeeded had at least one slip, and the study's summary reports an average of 14 slips over the two years. So success, in practice, included plenty of lapses.

The same study looked at what tended to come right before a slip: heavy stress, negative emotions and a feeling of having lost control. Those are ordinary features of life, not signs of a weak character. The 2002 study adds a hopeful detail. Confidence in your ability to change (psychologists call it self-efficacy), the skills needed to change, and readiness measured before January 1 all predicted better results. What you do in December counts.

Why resolutions break down

Different researchers and clinicians point to different causes. Here is each one, with a note on what kind of evidence backs it.

The goal is too big, and the start is too hard. Baylor psychiatrist Asim Shah names unrealistic or idealistic goals, paired with an overly aggressive start, as major reasons people give up. He recommends changing one thing at a time. (Clinical expert view.)

Later loses to now. Yale's School of Management describes hyperbolic discounting: when deciding what to do in the moment, an immediate reward can outweigh a bigger benefit that arrives later. The couch pays off tonight. Fitness pays off in spring. (Established behavioral-economics idea, applied here by Yale.)

The goal becomes part of how you judge yourself. Yale also describes identity attachment. When reaching a goal gets tied to self-worth, a setback can hurt motivation far more than the setback itself deserves. A missed workout starts to feel like proof of something. (Research summary.)

The old habit was doing a job. University of Washington psychologist Kevin King says people weigh the benefits of changing but overlook its costs, and overlook what their current routine gives them. Late-night scrolling may be how someone unwinds. Take it away without a replacement and the need stays. (Expert explanation.)

The plan skips the hard parts. On the American Psychological Association's podcast, psychologist Pauline Wallin says resolution plans often leave out how a person will handle predictable temptation, discomfort and setbacks. (Clinical expert view.)

January itself can make things harder. An employee-assistance handout hosted by the DEA lists winter darkness, cold, money pressure and stress as possible January obstacles. That's practical advice, not a controlled study showing January causes failure. Still, the bills from the holiday stretch between Thanksgiving and New Year's arrive just as the new routine is supposed to start.

The surroundings work against the plan. Mindy Hernandez of the World Resources Institute argues that personal effort depends partly on infrastructure and institutional support. Motivation can't add a bike lane or move a grocery store closer. (Expert argument.)

The method stops working, but the person keeps at it. Columbia Business School's January 5, 2026 research summary warns that number-based goals can make people stick with their first strategy. Comparing other methods can help them adjust. Tracking helps, but tracking without review can lock in a bad approach. (Research summary.)

What about willpower running out?

Many explainers on this topic say willpower is a limited fuel tank that empties as the day goes on, a theory known as "ego depletion." Presented that confidently, it doesn't hold up. A 2021 preregistered study (one whose methods were fixed in advance) ran across 36 laboratories with 3,531 participants. Its main analysis found no statistically significant ego-depletion effect, and the measured effect size was tiny (d = 0.06). That doesn't mean being tired never matters. It does mean "you ran out of willpower" is a weak explanation to build a plan around. Stress, triggers, rewards and environment are easier to change, and better supported.

Matching each cause to a fix

  • Goal too big → start smaller. Change one thing, as Shah suggests, and make it measurable. Loma Linda therapist Debra Schanck's example: instead of "eat out less," go from restaurant meals five times a month to twice a month.
  • Payoff too far away → add a reward now. UC Riverside psychologist Ian Ballard suggests saving a favorite podcast or TV episode for gym sessions only.
  • No cue to act → write an if–then plan. Yale recommends tying the action to a specific situation: "If it's 7 a.m. on a weekday, then I walk before checking email."
  • Obstacles in the way → arrange a backup ahead of time. Indiana's Department of Health trauma newsletter suggests a home workout or a shorter session when getting to the gym isn't realistic.
  • Perfectionism → measure improvement, not just hitting the target. Schanck describes someone aiming for five workouts a week who goes from two to four. They missed the target and still clearly improved.
  • Method not working → review and switch. Following Columbia's caution, set a date to ask whether the method is working, not just whether the number is moving.
  • Old habit meeting a need → find another way to meet it. Using King's point, name what the old routine provided and plan a substitute.

What a workable resolution looks like

These examples come from experts and health agencies. They're illustrations, not tested prescriptions:

  • Health: Turn "work out more" into a weekly target, with a home routine ready for icy mornings.
  • Money: Turn "spend less" into a specific limit, such as two restaurant meals a month instead of five.
  • Reading or hobbies: Indiana's newsletter turns "read more" into reading for 30 minutes before bed, twice a week, for three months.
  • Phone use: Ballard's example puts the phone in a closed drawer for the first hour after waking on weekdays, through January, followed by a review of what worked.
  • Relationships: Apply the same pattern: one specific action, a set time and a check-in date.

Each one has a clear action, a time frame and a built-in point to review. "Get healthy" has none of those.

What to do after a slip

Since slips are normal even among people who succeed, plan for them. NIH guidance recommends deciding ahead of time how you'll recover from a slip, tracking progress, getting support and remembering your own reasons for changing. Put together:

  1. Look at what happened. Was it stress, a bad mood or a sense of losing control, the triggers from the 1988 study? Or was it a scheduling problem?
  2. Remember why the change matters to you personally.
  3. Adjust the plan. Make it smaller, add a backup or change the method.
  4. Start again at the next chance. Don't wait for Monday or the first of the month.

One missed day is a data point, not a verdict.

Different people, different fixes

  • If you feel overwhelmed: keep the ambition but cut the starting workload. One change, as Shah advises.
  • If you're a perfectionist: count improvement, as Schanck does, and watch for the self-worth trap Yale describes.
  • If your current routine is how you cope: respect what it does for you, following King, and replace it rather than simply removing it.
  • If you have a tightly scheduled life: chef and athlete Dan Churchill argues that systems designed around perfect weeks are fragile. That's a practitioner's opinion, but it's a good reason to plan for messy weeks.
  • If your surroundings are the obstacle: Hernandez's point applies. Change what you can control, and don't blame yourself for what you can't.
  • If you're tired of constant self-improvement: philosopher Costica Bradatan reads the jokes about failed resolutions as relief from nonstop pressure to improve. It's an interpretation, not a measured cause, but it's a reasonable reminder that skipping the ritual is allowed.

Using the three weeks before January

The 2002 study found that readiness, skills and confidence measured before January 1 predicted success. That makes the end of the year a good time to plan, before December 31 forces the start. Pick one change. Write the if–then plan. Set up the backup. Choose an immediate reward. Put a review date on the calendar for late January. And decide now what you'll do after the first slip, because there will probably be one.

FAQ

What percentage of New Year's resolutions fail? No single reliable figure exists. In Pew's 2024 survey, 59% of resolution-makers said they'd kept all their resolutions by mid-January. Norcross and Vangarelli found 19% kept their pledges for two years. Popular claims like "only 8% succeed" or "80% fail by February" don't trace back to a clearly defined primary study.

Does one missed day mean I failed? Not according to the research. In the 1988 study, more than half of the people who succeeded had at least one slip.

Should I tell someone about my resolution? It depends on what kind of telling. Indiana's newsletter and NIH recommend getting support, while an MSU Denver psychologist cautions that announcing intentions can sometimes undermine action. Practical help, like a workout partner or someone to check in with, is different from collecting praise for an announcement. In the 1988 study, social support didn't predict success in the first six months but did predict it after that.

Do I have to wait until January? No. NIH notes that healthy changes can start at any point in the year. In Pew's survey, the most common reason people gave for not making resolutions was simply not liking them (56%), and that doesn't stop anyone from changing in March.

Does deliberately breaking a resolution help? It hasn't been shown to. Psychiatrist Richard A. Friedman, writing in The Atlantic about "paradoxical intent," notes that randomized clinical trials haven't tested the idea for New Year's resolutions.

Sources (20)