Fascinating facts about people, places and things
Actor in a red Santa suit with a full white beard, smiling beside a decorated Christmas tree
Comedians

Which Comedians Have Played Santa Claus?

Tim Allen, Leslie Nielsen, Ed Asner, John Goodman and Bill Hader all played Santa on screen. Here's which roles they played.

Halloween candy is still on the shelves, but the holiday movies are already back. You recognize the laugh under a Santa beard and can't quite place it. Here are the main answers. Tim Allen and Leslie Nielsen both played Santa Claus himself. Comic actors Ed Asner and John Goodman also played him. Bill Hader played the son who was supposed to take over the job. Billy Bob Thornton only wore the suit.

Tim Allen: the man who signed up without knowing it

This is a selection of well-known screen performances, not a complete list. "Comedians" is used loosely here to cover both comedians and comic actors, because screen-Santa casting rarely sticks to stand-up comics.

The best-known example is Tim Allen in The Santa Clause, released in the United States on November 11, 1994. Allen plays Scott Calvin, an ordinary dad who doesn't plan on becoming Santa. The title is a pun. The "clause" is a contract term: by putting on Santa's suit, Scott becomes responsible for doing Santa's job. Most of the film's comedy comes from Scott slowly finding out that he is now bound to the North Pole.

Allen played the role again much later. He returned as Scott Calvin in The Santa Clauses, a television series that picks up his story. Of all the performers here, he spent the longest playing the character, from a mid-1990s family comedy to a streaming-era series.

Leslie Nielsen: Santa loses his memory

Allen's Santa is a regular man who has to learn the job. Leslie Nielsen's character is the opposite: the real Santa, who forgets who he is. In Santa Who?, a television movie from 2000, Nielsen plays Santa Claus after he loses his memory.

The plot depends on a mix-up. A reporter helps the confused man get work as a department-store Santa, without realizing he is the real one. So the actual Santa ends up looking like just another man in a costume, and the joke is that nobody, including Santa himself, knows the truth.

Buster Keaton, the Great Stone Face, in a still from The Navigator (1924)
Related: Best Deadpan Comedians: Funny Without Cracking a Smile

Many viewers will know Nielsen from The Naked Gun, and the film's distributor uses that connection in its description of him. Santa Who? is not part of that franchise, though. It's a separate holiday movie that gives Nielsen's deadpan style a sweeter setting.

Ed Asner: the Santa from *Elf*

If the Santa you're thinking of is the one Buddy meets in Elf (2003), that's Ed Asner. People sometimes credit the role to Will Ferrell, but Ferrell plays Buddy, the human raised among elves. Asner plays Santa, the slightly worn-out boss of the North Pole whose sleigh depends on people's Christmas spirit.

Asner's comedy roots are in television. He played Lou Grant, the gruff newsroom boss on The Mary Tyler Moore Show. That background in playing a grumpy boss you can't help liking suits a Santa who has to deal with Buddy.

Elf wasn't his only time in the role. The International Santa Claus Hall of Fame, which inducted him, lists other Santa performances including The Story of Santa Claus, Olive, the Other Reindeer and Christmas on the Bayou. Those credits include different kinds of appearances, so it's safer to say Asner played Santa many times than to give an exact count.

John Goodman: a Santa ready to quit

Asner's Santa is tired. John Goodman's Santa is ready to quit. Goodman played Santa in the 2006 live-action television remake of The Year Without a Santa Claus.

In this version, Santa is fed up with how commercial Christmas has become. He wants to retire to Florida, which is about as far from the North Pole as you can get without leaving the country. The story is about whether anyone can bring back his holiday spirit before Christmas.

This is not the same production as the earlier stop-motion The Year Without a Santa Claus. The 2006 film is a live-action remake with real actors. If you remember a puppet Santa, you're thinking of the older version.

Goodman's Santa stands out because he's grumpy and still lovable. In Associated Press reporting on the remake, producer Mark Wolper described Goodman's Santa as warm even while grumpy. That balance keeps a Santa who wants to quit from turning into a real grinch.

Bill Hader: an heir who struggles with the job

Goodman's Santa wants to retire. In Noelle, the question is who takes over when a Santa steps down. Bill Hader plays Nick Kringle, who is expected to follow his father as Santa. Nick has trouble with the role. The family tradition comes with heavy expectations, and he doesn't feel ready.

The pressure gets to him, and Nick disappears as Christmas gets close. His sister, Noelle, has to go and find him, and her search drives the rest of the film.

Hader's role needs a qualifier. He doesn't play the established, experienced Santa the way Allen, Nielsen, Asner and Goodman do. He plays the heir who isn't sure he wants the job. That's still close enough to count when the question is which comedians played Santa, as long as you're clear about what the role actually is.

The Santa-suit exception: *Bad Santa*

One more performance often comes up in these conversations, but it belongs in a separate category. Billy Bob Thornton stars in Bad Santa (2003), and he spends much of the film in a Santa suit. His character is a criminal working as a mall Santa as a disguise. He's not the magical gift-giver, not his successor, and not someone who has forgotten he's Santa. He is just a man in costume.

That gives you a simple way to sort any funny screen Santa you come across this season:

  • Santa himself: Tim Allen (once Scott Calvin becomes Santa), Leslie Nielsen, Ed Asner and John Goodman.
  • An intended successor: Bill Hader as Nick Kringle, the heir who struggles with the job.
  • A character in costume: Billy Bob Thornton, whose Santa outfit is a disguise.

This isn't a ranking, and it isn't every comedian who has ever played Santa. It's a set of confirmed performances to start from, and it should be enough to put a name to that familiar laugh behind the beard.

Sources (14)